No Court Is An iLand (with apologies to John Donne)

iJustice Workflow Diagram

Not that typos never occur in this blog; but the capitalization in the title is not one. In considering the challenges of information and document flow through the justice system as a whole, I thought it appropriate to tie Donne’s observation[1] to ImageSoft iJustice[2],  an inter-agency integration tool, the very purpose of which is to connect the separate but inexorably linked enterprises of the justice system: court, prosecutor, law enforcement, jail, corrections, etc.

One of the emergent challenges manifesting itself within the justice system is that many, if not all, of the disparate systems across the myriad agencies of the justice system, having been developed separately and at different times, do not communicate well, with one another.    Thus the court and its close partners, although intimately linked at the business level, often reside on their own separate digital information islands.

Integration at the data level is a topic the sheer size of which too often discourages any consideration of how to facilitate better, more seamless communication.  But the fact is that a major portion of the communication challenge can be solved without touching the more daunting and costly data integration problem.

In the pre-digital era, communication and document movement across agencies operated using physical, paper documents.  This communication had little to do with the internal data systems (like the court’s Case Management System (CMS)or the jail’s Inmate Tracking System (ITS).  It was the lowest common denominator (paper) way to move information (and trigger action) from island to island.  In those olden days, “border crossings” did not seem unduly burdensome, as paper documents were created, then moved from agency to agency.

Now, with ECM, a court that migrates to electronic documents may be forced, in many instances, to print out hard copies to send to its partner agencies.   (I have in mind the image of Slim Pickens and his band of nasties having to stop to find dimes for a tollbooth placed in the middle of the desert to slow them down in Blazing Saddles.  It worked; in that it did slow them down.  So does having to print out electronic documents to send to other agencies.)

The paradigm embodied by ImageSoft iJustice advocates that, instead of embarking on the Herculean task of moving everyone to the same island, everyone keeps their own data systems but communicates using a common workflow and ECM engine.   The court keeps its CMS, the jail keeps its ITS, and so on.  The common ECM and workflow system moves documents across and through ALL of the agencies and systems.  (Here the image is the difference between using E-ZPass or stopping to pay and get change.)

This solution saves time “at the border” (on BOTH sides).  It also allows each agency to work on “internal” systems integration at its own pace, while all agencies get the benefit of common document management and workflow.

Moreover, the commonality of interest, coupled with the fact that integrated ECM with workflow requires much less money and effort than full cross-agency data system integration, makes the opportunities for cooperative multi-agency funding considerably more simple and attractive.  By sharing and leveraging the costs, each agency can potentially get MORE internal benefits (their own ECM and workflow) and IN ADDITION the benefits of streamlined communications and interactions, and expedited justice; with each of its partners for less up front and ongoing cost.


[1] “No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the Continent, a part of the Main…”, Devotions Upon Emergent Occasions, “Meditation XVII”, by John Donne, 1624.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s